The other day, I was browsing through the Kobo Bookstore when I came upon Robert Munsch’s The Paper Bag Princess. Immediately, my mind filled with happy memories of this beloved children’s book. I’ve never been one to resist an impulse buy, so within seconds the book was downloading on to my Kobo.
What happened next: a little bit of nostalgia paired with some disappointment. My device displayed the lovable writing and artwork I had remembered, but there was something different about it. That’s when I realized that the E Ink display completely took away from the experience of reading this classic book. My memories of the colourful images next to exciting passages were replaced with black ink on gray. Not to mention how odd it was to not have the text and pictures display all at once.
So this got me thinking about picture books on eReaders in general. Roxanne Weber commented on why parents are switching to eBooks for their children.
…eBooks are becoming even more popular as they become easier to carry on trips and have with us anywhere we go.
Given that so many young families are digitizing their daily lives, I asked myself how this option would affect the experience that children have reading them.
The understanding that I always had was that picture books are essential to a child’s learning, and that the colours only further help to develop a child’s brain and eyesight. So you can imagine the confusion I felt as I stared at the boring black and white versions of the drawings in Munsch’s book that had been separated from their accompanying text. Bianca Schulze has commented on the importance that children’s books play in child development.
The illustrations of a picture book help children understand what they are reading and allow young readers to analyze the story. When children are having difficulty, the illustrations can help them figure out the meaning of what they are reading… [Also, c]hildren love art. Why do you think they spend so much time coloring, drawing and doing crafts? Whatever the reason children are drawn towards a book, it’s a means to get them to read.
So if the images themselves are so important to children’s books, why aren’t many eBook distributors trying to do something about it? The answer I found was a little disappointing. Priya Ganapati reported that many E Ink devices will not be able to display colour for years to come due to technological issues.
For a color display, E Ink needs to put a color filter on top of its black-and-white display. A color filter usually has four sub-pixels—red, green, blue, and white —that are combined to create each full-color pixel. That also means reduced brightness of display.
This is pretty unfortunate news, considering the demand E Ink devices and eBooks. Until some progress is made, it looks like parents will have to make a decision about what they value more: experience or convenience.
You can purchase The Paper Bag Princess for Kobo here!